Fake AIPAC Lobbyist Created to Make Jews Look Like Monsters

Since bigots can’t find actual Jews who fit the monstrous archetype they’ve constructed in their heads, they have no choice but to invent them.

In the days following Tucker Carlson’s clash with Senator Ted Cruz over, among other things, AIPAC’s role in American politics, a curious wave of anti-AIPAC sentiment has swept across social media. A significant portion of it has centered on a now-deleted X account under the name “Jay Sullivan,” a self-described AIPAC lobbyist from Arkansas.

Jay’s posts were cartoonishly provocative — often cloaked in faux pro-Israel or pro-Jewish language, but transparent in their true intent. Anyone not already steeped in antisemitic conspiracies could recognize the posts as grotesque exaggerations designed to paint Jews as cruel, tribalist villains. Examples of posts include calling on the FBI to investigate Americans who disagree with the idea that Jews are “God’s chosen people” and saying that antisemites should be set on fire. One particular post that drew substantial ire declared: “Jewish lives matter more than anyone’s.”

Screenshot of “Jay’s” post

The backlash was swift. Antisemitic accounts piled on — see here, here, here and here, for example — replying with slurs and threats towards Jay and Jews in general. Additionally, for reasons unclear, Palestinian media decided to refer to Jay as a “U.S. senator.”

The account was eventually locked and deleted. Only one problem: Jay Sullivan doesn’t exist.

He’s a fabrication — a fake persona seemingly created by pro-Hamas, anti-Israel operatives to poison the discourse around AIPAC and inflame hatred toward Jews.

Millions of people have seen the post by “Jay Sullivan”

The Receipts

Based on the account’s bio, cover photo and profile picture alone, it’s easy to see that Jay is a complete fiction:

• “The Jay Show” and the Dynamic News Network he claimed to host it on don’t appear to exist anywhere online.

• No record exists of an AIPAC lobbyist out of Arkansas named Jay Sullivan.

• His listed employer, “Cyber Meta United States,” appears to be fake.

• He claimed to have co-founded “Mission Lane & Merik,” but no such business can be found.

• His profile photo is clearly AI-generated — as both AI detection tools and anybody with functioning eyeballs can attest.

A Trojan Horse Account

Even more revealing is what Jay actually posted before adopting the AIPAC persona. Archived posts show the account sharing pro-Hamas propaganda, defending Hamas, and excusing the October 7 massacre.

Jay has also amplified antisemites like Jake Shields, an MMA fighter turned Nazi-esque influencer, as well as Shahid Bolsen, an Islamist who murdered a man in the UAE and stuffed his corpse inside a suitcase. I kid you not.

The above posts archived here

It’s unclear exactly when “Jay” was pivoted from overt pro-Hamas rhetoric to posing as an over-the-top AIPAC loyalist. But the pivot itself reveals the deeper game: create a caricature of Jewish evil so grotesque that it justifies antisemitism in the eyes of the onlooker.

Manufactured Monsters

This incident underscores a broader trend. Since bigots can’t find actual Jews who fit the monstrous archetype they’ve constructed in their heads, they have no choice but to invent them. They create fake personas like Jay to serve as straw men for their hatred — characters so outrageous and morally bankrupt that they validate the bigot’s worldview.

Jay is likely part of a larger, coordinated disinformation effort. And the goal is clear: make Jews look inhuman, and make AIPAC the face of that inhumanity.